Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

You will not get the strut back on that way, you need to take the knuckle off too and fit that to the strut as there is not sufficient droop in the bottom arm to get the built strut back into the hub with the spring intact.

Posted
10 hours ago, ruffgeezer said:

You will not get the strut back on that way, you need to take the knuckle off too and fit that to the strut as there is not sufficient droop in the bottom arm to get the built strut back into the hub with the spring intact.

There is a small chance I might scrap the car with no spring on that side 😂 appreciate the heads up, I'm guessing you could hear the yelling and swearing from there...

I have hammers and a balljoint splitter. If nothing else it's good practice for when I've done nothing about the Sedici and end up deciding to put a clutch in it after all...

I can't quite bring myself to sign up for a Haval Jolion Pro just yet, but the Omoda 5 is tempting. Sadly, I want a Jaecoo 7 and they are quite expensive.

Posted

If the C3 is just to be scrapped could you not jam a length of wood where the shock was and stick the wheel back on?

Posted
35 minutes ago, Bear said:

....Sedici ..... clutch in it .....

image.png.ea8e4e3d79789c008e6dfcd546f115c9.png

Yer a braver man than I (and all that). If you do - lots of pictures ;-)

Posted
2 hours ago, MrBig said:

If the C3 is just to be scrapped could you not jam a length of wood where the shock was and stick the wheel back on?

There wouldn't be anything holding the hub upright :)

I have ordered some not-too-cheap spring compressors. I've used cheap ones before and my nerves can't take it.

The top bearing would be perfect if someone hadn't folded the sealing lip INSIDE the bearing. That's a pig to sort out and probably cheaper to replace the part, but might explain why the car had supposedly had new coil springs but was still noisy.
 

Posted

Ah yes. Dear old Earle Macpherson did not think that through did he!

Good spring compressors are absolutely worth every penny. A good friend of mine had an incident with one and was very lucky to not lose some of his fingers. The aftermath photos still give me the creeps.

I hope you get all this sorted as quickly and painlessly as possible, I've been in this situation before so you have my sympathies.

Posted

If you want a day trip, you can pop down to me and I'll fit the spring to your strut, I can arrange for a new bearing and top mount to be here for when you do?

I'd say bring the hub too and we can knock that back on at the same time.

I'll be honest though, on a marginal car I have bought an entire used strut and hub from Ebay in the past and just slung that on complete. 

Posted

Thing is, I probably won't scrap the C3, but I'm going to have to grit my teeth and SELL a used car, like a normal person sells a new car, i.e. act like this is just what cars should be.

It's done 70,000 miles and runs well, apart from the occasional hiccup from the gearbox which is normal-ish for a sensodrive and largely down to my girlfriend not being taught to use the handbrake. It's had a new battery, new starter-charging belt, has working (but due a regas after two years – I can hear the compressor would like more lube pls when running) aircon, hasn't got much rust, just had a new backbox...

BUT

It was accident repaired by a copart-car-dealer who CBA with prep, sanding, lacquer or replacing anything you couldn't see, so the nearside front wing looks manky and attempts to polish it make it worse, someone reversed into the boot with a pickup and bent the bit below the numberplate, it's missing front undertrays and the wheel arch liner I got was a third-party copy and is Not Very Good, the roof trim strips have shrunk, and the gearbox is a little rattly because when the clutch was replaced they clearly did a half-assed job (left all the wires loose, didn't replace seals, didn't calibrate the sensodrive so it was very snappy before I got hold of it).

It has been used as a daily runabout and I can't catch up with the year or so of neglect and bad garages it's had, but it's still better than most of the cheap two-pedal cars I've seen. A car dealer would have no hesitation sticking £1495 in the window and throwing a bucket of Mer over it then waiting for someone inexperienced and desperate for a ULEZ-compliant auto. As a 1.4 16v with stop start, when I've driven it I've been pretty impressed with the economy and performance - it's quick enough and handles quite well, the gearbox is not a problem if you remember to use the handbrake and feel for it biting just as you would with a manual. What it doesn't like is 'rolling back and snapping the clutch in', which is what happens if you drive it like an auto and don't know what the gearbox is doing. Once I explained this to gf, she hasn't had it cut out on a hill or do the beep beep beep NOPE thing.

GF wants a manual, I tried to get something we could both use to cut down on cars - this did not go to plan - so now I have the Volvo, she's getting the Spark, and the C3's getting the chop - but if I can sell it and get actual money that's pretty important right now for us.

Posted
9 minutes ago, ruffgeezer said:

If you want a day trip, you can pop down to me and I'll fit the spring to your strut, I can arrange for a new bearing and top mount to be here for when you do?

I'd say bring the hub too and we can knock that back on at the same time.

I'll be honest though, on a marginal car I have bought an entire used strut and hub from Ebay in the past and just slung that on complete. 

The only one I saw was £40 and looked like it was from an amphibious C3 used for channel crossings :D 

The price for new replacement strut assemblies seems to have gone right up, too - I am sure they were £169 or thereabouts when my dad needed one for his Picasso (it did much the same thing and I said it was cheaper to get the strut and swap it than pay for the labour rebuilding the old one), now they are much more - but I didn't find many listed.

The spring was £20, so I'm not too worried - I'd like the day trip, but will save it for Volvo nerding instead (the fuel would pay for the parts to fix the C3). I've done struts and springs before on other cars, I just have the arse with this car because it's eating time and unlike mine, where I can swap into a different car or just not go anywhere, she needs to drive every day so downtime is bad.

Sometimes I need to get just pissed off enough to finish the task, like "now I need a BIGGER hammer". But I prefer it without the pissed off, like doing the Insight shocks which did not involve one swear word at all and practically had the Tony Hart art music playing while I calmly set the torque wrench and double checked everything before a final clean and putting the wheels back on.

Posted
28 minutes ago, Bear said:

Thing is, I probably won't scrap the C3, but I'm going to have to grit my teeth and SELL a used car, like a normal person sells a new car, i.e. act like this is just what cars should be.

It's done 70,000 miles and runs well, apart from the occasional hiccup from the gearbox which is normal-ish for a sensodrive and largely down to my girlfriend not being taught to use the handbrake. It's had a new battery, new starter-charging belt, has working (but due a regas after two years – I can hear the compressor would like more lube pls when running) aircon, hasn't got much rust, just had a new backbox...

BUT

It was accident repaired by a copart-car-dealer who CBA with prep, sanding, lacquer or replacing anything you couldn't see, so the nearside front wing looks manky and attempts to polish it make it worse, someone reversed into the boot with a pickup and bent the bit below the numberplate, it's missing front undertrays and the wheel arch liner I got was a third-party copy and is Not Very Good, the roof trim strips have shrunk, and the gearbox is a little rattly because when the clutch was replaced they clearly did a half-assed job (left all the wires loose, didn't replace seals, didn't calibrate the sensodrive so it was very snappy before I got hold of it).

It has been used as a daily runabout and I can't catch up with the year or so of neglect and bad garages it's had, but it's still better than most of the cheap two-pedal cars I've seen. A car dealer would have no hesitation sticking £1495 in the window and throwing a bucket of Mer over it then waiting for someone inexperienced and desperate for a ULEZ-compliant auto. As a 1.4 16v with stop start, when I've driven it I've been pretty impressed with the economy and performance - it's quick enough and handles quite well, the gearbox is not a problem if you remember to use the handbrake and feel for it biting just as you would with a manual. What it doesn't like is 'rolling back and snapping the clutch in', which is what happens if you drive it like an auto and don't know what the gearbox is doing. Once I explained this to gf, she hasn't had it cut out on a hill or do the beep beep beep NOPE thing.

 

Sounds a perfect candidate for selling on here, possibly in 59 small payments...

Posted
57 minutes ago, robt100 said:

Sounds a perfect candidate for selling on here, possibly in 59 small payments...

That was what I was going to do if the spring repair doesn't show up any new problems :)

Posted

Went to fit the cleaned passenger seat to the Sedici. The back is bent on this one as well.

It's pretty obvious that the car was being broken and someone's chucked a load of heavy parts in there and wrecked the interior after it was exposed to the elements, what I don't understand is how the seller could get that interior and not go "well that's shite" and tell me it was no good, instead of pressing on and selling it.

Really more pissed off than 500 characters of negative feedback can sum up.

Posted

One Spark collected - absolutely bricking it because the Volvo's wheelbearings have gone from "nowt of note" to "argh wheel's gonna fall off" in the space of half a tank of diesel.

GF drove the Spark back (first time solo a manual in years) and no fears but "car shaking" - she thought the wrong gear, but nah, sticking caliper from sitting around. I took it for a spin and a couple of aggressive stops got it to back off, so I'll strip and grease the sliders etc.

But she did report smoke coming from the Volvo a few times. I wonder if it was the spray from the headlight washers.

Definitely doing Volvo bearings ASAP 😂

@petermcpete has kept the Chevrolet in fine shape, engine sounds Honda-smooth and the lack of horses is less apparent when the brake isn't gripping on like a limpet - and gf thinks it is easier than a Panda to drive. Quite a funky sub-Corsa weird thing, the Spark, and the dash design is very cool! Also cheapest insurance yet.

  • Like 3
Posted

I would take up ruff geezers offer of fitting the spring, the c3 spring I changed was tapered from top to bottom and the compressors did not fit it well, i.e it was sketchy as fuck. But a stupidly got away with it.

When I had to have a top mount changed I just took the strut to a local garage, there was no way I was attempting that again.

Citroen Peugeot are aware this is a problem and made this, and made this safety perch to stop the spring going into the tyre, am sure some cars were recalled to have em fitted too. Mine didn't have them.

Screenshot_20250328-211642.png.5099b3c0c53225e0b8771c2c710bdb68.png

Posted

This spring design wasn't as batshit as the Picasso one - I think the compressors I've ordered will do the trick, but I'd want to visit @ruffgeezer to talk shite and fix cars anyway if it weren't for the hours of road in the way.

Posted
25 minutes ago, Bear said:

One Spark collected - absolutely bricking it because the Volvo's wheelbearings have gone from "nowt of note" to "argh wheel's gonna fall off" in the space of half a tank of diesel.

My old V70 (still with @Cord Fourteener I think?)  did that too, very handily whilst I was travelling to derby once a week, I don't really remember changing it so it can't have been too bad to do on the drive at the weekend.

Posted

Hmm. Mine also did it when travelling to Derby. I think Volvo Estates should not be allowed near Derby.

If anyone near Derby has a Volvo Estate they want to save, please message me and I'll keep it safe.

Posted

Early morning car prodding...

IMG_8750.jpeg.80dc9c95063ddfa9f1ac3fccea629cc6.jpeg

Crude "sticking brakes alleviation" is just a load of wheel cleaner (I did all four wheels anyway - this was a before pic to show the under-arch/sill ends when I'd got the mud off) and then a jetwash until all the brake dust crap stops flowing out from behind the wheel. It's not a fix - it'll need sliders and pad guides de-rusting at the very least, but she needed to drive it today and to be fair I'd got them freed off a bit with a bit of abuse yesterday.

IMG_8751.jpeg.956dd5c1457ad7aef83c20d8cad59ada.jpeg

I'll get things like this cleaned and it'll look disproportionately better, I think.

IMG_8752.jpeg.21b6174b62487276679cd0f4e97d8f6e.jpeg

But someone likes it and is obviously feeling confident about it!

IMG_8753.jpeg.05adb248e4875bb171da687673dbceb9.jpeg

IMG_8754.jpeg.c29c929dc680423d9ebc150fb917c646.jpeg

It is a more basic car than her C3, but 6 years newer is a bonus, and I see lots of nice silver paint under the arches so I'll do the waxoyl and stuff and it should stay easy to maintain and sensible.

First upgrade will be replacing the radio with an Android head unit  and reversing camera. Second upgrade will be some form of boot release 😂

  • Like 3
Posted
12 hours ago, ruffgeezer said:

My old V70 (still with @Cord Fourteener I think?)  did that too, very handily whilst I was travelling to derby once a week, I don't really remember changing it so it can't have been too bad to do on the drive at the weekend.

They look very easy - technically anyway - four bolt hub assembly over driveshaft, so it's just how much the brakes and bits want to argue. Can't decide if the £36 part is going to be 1/2 as good as the £65 part, or if the £65 part is the £36 one with a once-respected brand name now attached via a holding company that's just buying in the same cheap crap. Because if it's the latter I may as well do both front ones and at least narrow down the noises somewhat.

Posted

First signs of spring

image.jpg.04e36535427809da54ce60a1adfc2a26.jpg

yeah that's a longboi with a bit of bend to it. I'm afraid.

Hydraulic spring compressors are £97 on Amazon. How deadly could they be?

Posted

Not as deadly as my manual ones (as said above - they're sketchy, I do the 'buy a complete, secondhand strut' now) - I'd take that to a nice garageman with a pukka tool and pay him 

  • Agree 2
Posted
On 16/07/2024 at 00:21, Bear said:

 

IMG_4150.jpeg.67ee38f02fc96a12f09beb13553a9e64.jpeg

Spot the difference?

IMG_4151.jpeg.266305a4c3fcd19f614f91134ec15a30.jpeg

Fixed the clock stalk with the repro pieces.

IMG_4153.jpeg.e61376b00e91711767cf4df0e9350b23.jpeg

This isn't a trim cover, it's designed to hold a microphone! Very neat.

Just reading through this highly enjoyable thread of your car-related activities from the last few years...

How did you replace the stalks on the Boxster cluster?? I need to do one of mine ..!

Posted
On 28/03/2025 at 21:07, bigfella2 said:

I would take up ruff geezers offer of fitting the spring, the c3 spring I changed was tapered from top to bottom and the compressors did not fit it well, i.e it was sketchy as fuck. But a stupidly got away with it.

When I had to have a top mount changed I just took the strut to a local garage, there was no way I was attempting that again.

Citroen Peugeot are aware this is a problem and made this, and made this safety perch to stop the spring going into the tyre, am sure some cars were recalled to have em fitted too. Mine didn't have them.

Screenshot_20250328-211642.png.5099b3c0c53225e0b8771c2c710bdb68.png

Do you have a link for these please? I tried and failed to get a pair to put on my picasso, I've just slung a set of new tyres on so I'd much rather they didn't get punctured by a spring making a bid for freedom!

Posted
3 hours ago, RoverFolkUs said:

Do you have a link for these please? I tried and failed to get a pair to put on my picasso, I've just slung a set of new tyres on so I'd much rather they didn't get punctured by a spring making a bid for freedom!

I think they'll be NLA - we had a discussion on the BerlingoForum on these about 8 years ago when mine popped a tyre due to the spring going - they were mentioned but nobody had (or could find) any.
Part numbers were:

Right hand: 5031A4 
Left hand :   5031A5 

[edit] @RoverFolkUs try PN 5031E8 - that was the suggestion for my Berlingo but I never followed it up. CatCar.info here is saying 5031E7 on a Xsara Picasso DV6TED - that could L and R handed? (Both those part numbers available t buy on t'interweb) 

Posted

Ah, Stellantis. 12 year body warranty, ten year spare parts supply, six if it's likely to make the car dangerous or unusuable.

Posted

Sheer bloodymindedness:

 

IMG_8766.jpeg

IMG_8765.jpeg

IMG_8764.jpeg

IMG_8763.jpeg

IMG_8769.jpeg

IMG_8770.jpeg

  • Like 3
Posted
2 hours ago, Cluffy said:

Just reading through this highly enjoyable thread of your car-related activities from the last few years...

How did you replace the stalks on the Boxster cluster?? I need to do one of mine ..!

Kit from eBay for about £30 I think, dash out, undo a couple of screws to separate the back and front, pop new sticks in, attach knobs, reassembly is the reverse. It was very easy - the dash is straightforward to remove. Plus you can enjoy the segments for 911s and how they're hidden on the Boxster (and unpopulated but could be).

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...